Good news for people who like bad news:
- The Housing Bubble Blog (formerly housingbubble2)
- Bubble Track (blog)
- Bubble Meter (blog)
- Housing Bubble (blog) – Apparently Housing Bubble’s last entry in September was so exhausting that they gave up or they declared victory – you decide.
- Seattle bubble (blog) – a much longer list of bubble sites here
And a couple of articles:
- Speaking Truth or Crying Wolf? (article)
- The bubble bellwether index (article)
And if those aren’t enough, I suggest the tongue-in-cheek There is no Housing bubble!
It sure is easy to be a hater, isn’t it?
I think both sides are taking a foolish black-and-white approach to the bubble question; clearly there are some indicators that there is a real estate bubble, but the consensus seems to be that the risk of home prices plummeting is low. Home prices will probably be flat until inflation brings prices back to “normal” levels. My concern is that if house prices do pop precipitously, there are going to be serious consequences for home owners and non-homeowners alike.
A similar scenario, different context: A few years ago, the Fed found itself with a small risk of Very Bad Thing happening. That Very Bad Thing was deflation (remember that?). Few economists were convinced that actual Japan-style deflation would occur, but because of the potentially devastating effect of deflation on the economy, the Fed moved aggressively to combat it (giving us the cheap money we used to buy expensive homes) even though the solution could cause other problems. Why? Here is the economist (login required) in 2002 (slightly out of context):
… however small the risk of deflation, the economic cost would be so high that policymakers should respond as if it were a central risk.
Someone who is looking at a home today or who has a sizeable mortgage on their home today should look at all this bubble talk in the same way; the risk is low that your property value will decline 25% or even 10%, but the risk is certainly there. Specifically:
- Do you have enough savings or equity to stay above water if your house loses 10% in value?
- Is the risk of falling property values worth the potential upside?
- If it isn’t a bubble now, what metrics or signs will you use to tell you if or when it is a bubble? (A corollary: Will those metrics tell you when it is a bubble or when the bubble is popping?)
Perhaps house valuations have fundamentally changed over the last 5-10 years and we there is no risk of house price declines. The one argument I do not buy is that our land use laws are making property more expensive; builders are cranking out hundreds units and making loads of money on each unit, meaning they could continue profiting even at lower price levels.
Galen